This is a proposal for modifying the trackDb release process developed by Brian, Brooke, and Markd. It is intended as a straight-forward modification to the existing process to address some of the current problems; not as a major, comprehensive change.
This addresses the following issues:
- Release tags currently do not prevent modifications to tracks already on the RR from leaking to the RR while in QA. This is caused by the release tag not accurately modeling the process. This is addressed by adding a third state: "public".
- Managing releases of updated versions of ENCODE composite tracks is complex, requiring editing a potentially large number of release tags in trackDb.ra stanza files. Also, the release tag doesn't currently work on the composite track stanza.
Updated trackDb release process
The three state trackDb (and hgFindSpec) release process is:
- alpha state: make alpha run on hgwdev loads all tracks with release alpha into trackDb and hgFindSpec regardless of the table existing.
- beta state: make beta run on hgwbeta loads all tracks with release beta into trackDb and hgFindSpec only if the table exists.
- public state: make public run on hgwbeta loads all tracks with release public into trackDb_public and hgFindSpec_public only if the table exists.
Having no release tag is equivalent to having all 3 release tags present.
QA can look at trackDb_public on hgwbeta-public.cse.ucsc.edu as a final check before pushing it to the RR. Then trackDb_public and hgFindSpec_public will be pushed from mysqlbeta to mysqlrr, renaming them to trackDb and hgFindSpec.
Tracks that don't already exist on the RR function as they do now:
- Developer creates table(s) and adds a corresponding stanza to trackDb.ra, with no release tags
- QA pushes table to mysqlbeta, does a make beta, and QAs track
- When track is ready, QA does a make public, then pushes the tables and trackDb_public to mysqlrr, renaming them to trackDb
If a developer subsequently wants to make changes to the track, it would work like this:
- the old stanza:
track someTrack shortLabel Mediocre RNAs visibility hide
- becomes two stanzas:
track someTrack release alpha shortLabel Great RNAs visibility pack
track someTrack release beta,public shortLabel Mediocre RNAs visibility hide
- nothing leaks out to the RR before it is ready. QA looks at the changes on hgwbeta by changing the first stanza to release alpha,beta and the second stanza to release public
- when it is deemed worthy, the trackDb.ra entry can be collapsed back to one stanza, with no release tags (although leaving release alpha,beta,public in there would have the exact same effect):
track someTrack shortLabel Great RNAs visibility pack
Managing large composite tracks
To address this issue, each large composite track will be moved to its own file with all of its contained track stanzas. To minimize the amount of editing required, the include directive will be modified to have a release attribute. Since includes are processed line-per-line, not as part of a stanza, an attribute is an easier approach than adding a release tag.
For example, if a developer created the file wgEncodeGencode.ra, the following line could be added to trackDb.ra (or trackDb.wgEncode.ra, or whatever):
include wgEncodeGencode.ra alpha
When QA gets it, this will become:
include wgEncodeGencode.ra alpha,beta
And when it is released:
(no release restrictions is the same as having: alpha,beta,public)
Updating existing public tracks
When changes need to be made to an already-released composite track, the composite trackDb file is copied to a new file name and it is added to git. So two copies of the entire file will exist (the *.new.ra having all the new changes/updates) and trackDb.ra will look like:
include wgEncodeGencode.new.ra alpha include wgEncodeGencode.ra beta,public
When the track is in QA and staged on hgwbeta, this will become:
include wgEncodeGencode.new.ra alpha,beta include wgEncodeGencode.ra public
To release the new version, QA will:
cp wgEncodeGencode.new.ra wgEncodeGencode.ra
commit the changes. And change the include line back to:
The changes won't leak to the RR before QA approves them and removes the release restrictions on the include directive (which is equivalent to a release restriction of alpha,beta,public).
Updating a track that is mid-QA
Often, a developer needs to start more work on a track before it is through the QA process and released and make the changes visible on genome-test for data contributors. In this case, a third file can be created and committed to git:
include wgEncodeGencode.latestForContributor.ra alpha #name is arbitrary include wgEncodeGencode.new.ra beta include wgEncodeGencode.ra public
When QA of the original update is complete that change released, the developer is free create a pushQ entry for it. QA can copy the latest version to wgEncodeGencode.new.ra when ready to move it to beta. Once the latest changes have been git committed to wgEncodeGencode.new.ra and there are no include directives for the arbitrarily-named wgEncodeGencode.latestForContributor.ra file, the latter can be git removed.
IT SEEMS LIKE THIS IS PROBABLY FIXED in 2011 AND YOU CAN IGNORE THIS SECTION.
When you add new tracks to previously released super-tracks, the old paradigm of needing a table + trackDb entry in order for your track to be anything but completely invisible on the RR *does not apply*. So, if you are adding a new track to a super-track that is already on the RR, even though the tables are not yet on the RR, you must use release tags.
Currently, if you do not use release tags and add a new track to a super-track, users will be able to see your new track listed on the super-track control page. However, when the user tries to turn it on, they won't see anything. When the user tries to go to the hgTrackUi page, they will get an error.
This issue is documented in redmine: http://redmine.soe.ucsc.edu/issues/2046.
As of May, 2012, release tags apply to search stanzas in trackDb.ra as well as to track stanzas. Galt's comments on the topic:
"hgFindSpec now takes -release=<tag>, where tag is alpha, beta, or public. If no release is specified, alpha is the default. It works on both include and stanza levels. It supports the standard root/org/db levels. It does not have the fancy superTrack, subTrack, views, etc. issues that trackDb has. searchName must be unique for the given release tag. It will errAbort with a message if it finds a duplicate. loadTracks now sends the -release option to hgFindSpec."
Some keywords for easier searching: 3-state, three, three-state, three state.